Friday, November 13, 2026

A Goodreads Choice TBR and a few thoughts about Yesteryear

A sure sign of autumn for most bookish folk is the announcement that voting has begun for the 
 Goodreads Choice Awards , where you get to decide what is the best book of the year in several categories. The opening round started this past Tuesday (with 20 nominees in each section) and the final voting period (down to 10 by then) is expected to begin on November 24, with the winners announced on December 3.

Granted, Goodreads has a love/hate relationship with many readers for various reasons but, also, some of us just find the Choice Awards to be mainly for fun and nothing more than that.

 Critiquing it is fine(not to mention part of the entertainment value) but after the very hectic real life election cycle we’ve been through, this is a relaxing way to wrap up your reading year.

It’s also a great excuse to set up a new To Be Read pile there! While I was happy to find plenty of favorite books to vote for, I did see that there were many others that I do need to get to(yes, a good number of them are Book of the Month selections).

For example, Lady Tremaine by Rachel Hochhauser is up for Best Historical Fiction and Best Debut novel, nice going there! This story is a twist on Cinderella as the title stepmother searches for a way to stay connected to her newly wed stepdaughter, who is now a member of the royal family.

That family, however, has a rather nasty secret that this stepmother-in-law could use to her advantage but the price for that may be higher than even she is willing to pay.

I do enjoy an interesting take on villainous characters, especially in fantasy/fairytale settings, and hopefully I will get to turning these delightful pages before my reading list turns into a pumpkin:


Another charming book that I have been meaning to get to is This Book Made Me Think of You by Libby Page. 

This nominee in Best Romance is set at a bookstore, where widow Tilly has been left quite the birthday present by her late husband.

It seems that he put together a stack of twelve books for her to read over the course of a year, to be handed out by Alfie, the bookshop owner. Each book also comes with a prompt of sorts to encourage Tilly to get out into the world and renew her spirits.

While this does sound sad, the story does have positive energy as it showcases the emotional healing that books can offer people. Not to mention that it’s giving off solid You’ve Got Mail vibes, one of my favorite fall movies, and why have I not read this by now?!:


Now, one of the Choice Awards categories that I really need to catch up on is Fantasy as I have a number of must reads there.

One of those is Ilona Andrews ‘ This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me, one of the most talked about books of the year! This first in a series has Maggie, who becomes known as Maggie the Undying in the realm of Kair Toren due to her remarkable resurrection skills. That ability comes from the fact that she’s not supposed to be here at all.

Back in our world, Maggie frequently reread the first two books of her favorite fantasy series, anxiously awaiting for the story to be completed. Through an unexpected portal, she finds herself trapped in the fictional universe that she loves and tries to use her vast knowledge of the story to alter a few plot lines that might save some of her favorite characters from their intended fates.

That is such a great starting point for a fantasy series! I haven’t read Andrews before but this seems to be a wonderful place to start and with any luck, I can have this literary journey under way before the next entry arrives in the new year:


Well, my early votes are in and when the finals begin, I hope to see many of my picks in that selection. 

While this is not as serious as the other book award competitions , out there, the Goodreads Choice is one that does directly engages the reader for their input and can be seen as a reflection of what’s on the minds of book people at a particular point in time. That ought to count for something, if you ask me.

One of those books of the moment is Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke, which I finished this week and returned to my local library in the pouring rain (hey, it was due back sooner than I thought). This book is up for Best Fiction, Best Debut Novel and I believe for Best Audiobook as well at the Choice Awards, it’s that huge!

The basic plot revolves around Natalie Heller Mills, a woman who appears to have it all as a “tradwife” social media influencer on her family’s farm with her husband Caleb and their numerous children. However, things are truly not what they seem and as Natalie’s world is on the edge of collapse, a sudden twist changes everything all at once.

I won’t say more than that for those who haven’t read YY yet but I can say after all of the hype both good, bad and In between, this book was better than expected in the best sense.

As we follow Natalie on more than one life experience throughout the story, you get a real sense of seeing a slow motion disaster in the making, almost like watching an intensely made yet fascinating documentary. While she’s never a pleasant person, Natalie is the one thing that a main character needs to be and that’s interesting.

So many people get hung up on whether or not a character is “relatable “ or nice but for me, these fictional folk have to be interesting enough for me to keep with their story. Hero, villain, average person-doesn’t matter as long as they are created with talent by an author who knows what they are doing.

Caro Claire Burke definitely fits that bill and takes what could have easily been a superficial stereotype and breathes life into her on each and every page

 The story does touch down on the tradwife trend but also the effects of being raised on camera and how women are always expected to present themselves in a pleasing manner, especially on social media and so many other things. Yet, at it’s core is the human price to be paid by our leading lady for the image she feels obligated to maintain, not just for financial reasons but for her own sense of identity as well.

Yesteryear is certainly a memorable book and I did vote for it at the Goodreads Choice in at least two categories. Will it hold up over the course of time? We shall see, particularly when the movie adaptation hits theaters in the near future. I personally think it has a solid chance at being a hallmark of this turbulent timeline we’re in and hopefully the first of many more good books from this author. 

In the meantime, do check out the Goodreads Choice for a bit of fun speculation as this year get ready to pack up and go into storage, so to speak.

Oh, and when it comes to the Yesteryear movie, Anne Hathaway is most assuredly going to crush it as Natalie. A lot of other factors are involved with film making, I know, but Hathaway definitely has the chops and perhaps an Oscar in waiting for this role of a lifetime:







No comments: